MAIB Publish Shearwater and Agem 1 Report

Immobilisation and flooding of dredger Shearwater following repeated collisions with unmanned barge Agem One



On 9 April 2020 near Kinlochbervie, Scotland, the UK registered dredger Shearwater was immobilised after its propeller shafts were fouled by its own towline, which was being used to tow the unmanned barge, Agem One. Thereafter, Shearwater was damaged and holed, resulting in flooding, after repeated collisions with Agem One, which was no longer under control. The situation was eventually stabilised after the intervention of a lifeboat, a workboat and an emergency towing vessel.

Safety Issues

  • Shearwater was not a suitable vessel to conduct a lengthy coastal tow, and there was insufficient planning or safety procedures for the voyage
  • Shearwater’s crew did not have the necessary competence for the towing voyage, and there was no tow master
  • Safety certification by the flag state did not provide sufficient assurance for safe operation of the vessel


Recommendations (2021/124 and 2021/125) have been made to Shearwater’s owner to assess all on board hazards and provide safe systems of work to mitigate the foreseeable risks, and to ensure the vessel is safely manned.

Our report also makes a recommendation (2021/123) to the Maritime and Coastguard Agency to ensure that certification of vessels such as Shearwater includes the application of all appropriate regulatory conditions relevant to the vessel’s intended function and area of operations.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *